April 1st, 2014 Brian Herzog
But more recently, a post on the Massachusetts Law Updates blog caught my eye - it was titled You can get jail time for making noise in a Massachusetts library.
Turns out, Massachusetts General Law chapter 272, section 41 states:
Whoever wilfully disturbs persons assembled in a public library, or a reading room connected therewith, by making a noise or in any other manner during the time when such library or reading room is open to the public shall be punished as provided in the preceding section.
And the punishment from the preceding section was eye-opening:
...imprisonment for not more than thirty days or by a fine of not more than one hundred dollars, or both...
We had no idea this law existed. However, at their meeting last night, our Trustees voted to change our Acceptable Library Behavior policy to reflect this law. They felt having a policy not in line with an existing law was legally-indefensible, so we'd be leaving the library open to litigation.
So from now on, any patron who "wilfully disturbs persons" in my library is going to jail.
June 13th, 2009 Brian Herzog
In my library, the reference area is downstairs. This is also where most of the computers are, as well as our quiet study room.
Since the library's main entrance is upstairs, many patrons go to the circulation desk first, and then are sent downstairs with their question. I don't know this to be true, but I suspect the circ staff gets malicious pleasure from some of the patrons they send down.
To wit: A woman carrying a few books, a stack of library CDs, and a portable CD player walks down the steps and comes to the desk...
Patron: The people upstairs said you could show me where a quiet room is?
Me: Sure, it's right down here. But it's not completely quiet - if someone is being loud outside the room you might hear them, but let me know and I'll ask them to be quiet.
Patron: Oh, I'm not worried about that, but I didn't want anyone bothered by me.
Patron: I want to practice singing opera, and I thought they said your quiet room was sound proof.
I waited for her to crack a smile, but she didn't - she was dead serious.
When I hemmed and hawed about the singing, she decided to just use a computer instead. She was listening to her Discman while using the computer, and after a few minutes started humming along with the music. There were only a couple patrons using computers nearby, and none of them seemed bothered so I let it go.
I feel bad whenever we can't accommodate someone's request, but I guess library patrons are just far more creative than library building designers.