Ahmadinejad Classification System
August 26th, 2010I recently noticed in our Reference collection one of the quirks of the Dewey Decimal System that people often refer to as "serendipitous" - but look at the picture below to see if you also see a problem:
The books that caught my eye are these (biggify the photo to see the Dewey numbers):
- Ref/809.927/Prin - Imaginary people: a who's who of modern fictional characters
- Ref/809.933/Ency/2002 - Encyclopedia of Holocaust literature
- Ref/809.933/Mang/Pb - The dictionary of imaginary places
And here's the Dewey breakdown:
809 - History, description, critical appraisal of more than two literatures
809.91-.92 - Literature displaying specific qualities and elements
809.933 - Literature dealing with specific themes and subjects
I didn't see .927 described in either DDC21 or DDC22, but it was the call number specified in that book's CIP data (©1987), so it must have been phased out long ago.
And so, I get that these books are each about specific kinds of literature. But come on - a book about the Holocaust shelved between two books about imaginary things? It really is like Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and other fool Holocaust deniers got into OCLC and caused this to happen - a cataloger sleeper cell.
I'm going to talk with my Head of Technical Services to see how we can fix this.
August 26th, 2010 at 1:51 pm
Some of the confusion may be that the call numbers aren’t long enough. According to Worldcat, the “Holocaust Lit” book should be 809.93358 and the “Dictionary of Imaginary Places” should be 809.93372. That should put other books on similar topics next to each other. (There aren’t any official breaks in the call numbers. The typist of the spine labels may have cut them off because s/he ran out of room.)
I’m not sure about “Imaginary People.” I’m not a cataloger so I don’t know how to tease out the details on that one, but if that call number isn’t in DDC then the book probably should be recataloged.
Dewey definitely does have some quirks.
August 26th, 2010 at 3:55 pm
haha — good call on that “cataloger sleeper cell”
(this entry was a good chuckle)
August 26th, 2010 at 5:50 pm
I had to check our library’s catalog, and fortunately, our “Encyclopedia of Holocaust Lit” resides at 809.9335, between “The buried book : the loss and rediscovery of the great Epic of Gilgamesh” and “Gay and Lesbian lit”. Phew!
September 10th, 2010 at 9:10 am
[…] Sometimes, though? Really, truly doesn’t work all that well. […]
February 25th, 2011 at 12:07 pm
[…] Swiss Army Librarian » Ahmadinejad Classification System :: Brian … […]
May 2nd, 2012 at 7:12 am
[…] May 2nd, 2012 I know I've given the Dewey Decimal System a hard time for its quirks, and have experimented with other shelving systems when Dewey wasn't getting the job done. But […]